Shout Box archive

03 Jul 17:46

Amit Dutta

--

wrote it wrong haha. be willing to listen, no obligation to hear and enact what they say

03 Jul 17:46

Mechanizoid

--

Be open to those who would like to help you, but don't hang on to anything that isn't helpful.

03 Jul 17:45

Mechanizoid

--

It sounds contradictory but I get what you mean. :-)

03 Jul 17:45

Amit Dutta

--

and at the same time be willing to listen to pretty much everybody

03 Jul 17:45

Amit Dutta

--

That's why you should never listen to pretty much everybody

03 Jul 17:44

Mechanizoid

--

Yeah, I don't give a shit about these definitions either. I was a bit sensitized after being told repeatedly that what I want to do is "not REAL art" though. LOL

03 Jul 17:42

Amit Dutta

--

I literally don't give a shit personally what art is defined as. I leave the definitions up to people who like to make definitions. I am interested in certain aspects of when art becomes art in a specific context, but I don't want to talk about that in here since I'm writing a story based on it :).

03 Jul 17:41

Mechanizoid

--

Not accusing of "this guy belongs, this guy doesn't" thinking, of course, it's just that these kinds of definitions start leading us in that direction. I got enough of this shit from my "fine artist" relations TBH.

03 Jul 17:40

Mechanizoid

--

Also, concept artists are doing the same kind of stuff (drawing and painting), it's just not for a finished product. Honestly, the whole thing smacks of "this guy belongs, this guy doesn't" thinking. We are all artists if we are creating. :-)

03 Jul 17:38

Mechanizoid

--

It's kind of hopeless, LOL.

03 Jul 17:38

Mechanizoid

--

Or is it only art if I shellac dog shit and put in a museum?

03 Jul 17:38

Mechanizoid

--

I mean, is it art only if I illustrate, but not if I concept?

03 Jul 17:37

Mechanizoid

--

Also, it starts to get into arguments over exclusivity and belonging. Who counts as an "artist"?

03 Jul 17:37

Mechanizoid

--

@Amit But what is art anyway? When we start down that path it doesn't get us anywhere.

03 Jul 17:35

Amit Dutta

--

no, I mean over the years I've seen the idea mostly only used to talk about writing and authors. it's very relevant to anybody trying to sell their own creative works to people.

03 Jul 17:11

Brian Hermelijn

--

Because the article itself is not directed for authors/writers only, rather, I can see it been applied in many other fields. Especially with the possibilities we have nowadays over the internet.

03 Jul 17:10

Brian Hermelijn

--

Do you mean it's only applicable to those 2 fields or?

03 Jul 16:49

Amit Dutta

--

Yeah that long tail stuff, is very relevant, but you'll mostly only see it talked about in the context of authors and writing...

03 Jul 15:19

Brian Hermelijn

--

Applicable to those trying to make a living as a stand alone person.

03 Jul 15:19

Brian Hermelijn

--

And before I jump off, an article that speaks about 1,000 True fans, http://kk.org/thetechnium/1000-true-fans/

03 Jul 15:05

Brian Hermelijn

--

What will the CC of this month be?

03 Jul 14:57

Brian Hermelijn

--

True.

03 Jul 14:47

Amit Dutta

--

hmmm kinda. but that's too restrictive. Also a fashion designer, genetic designer, world designer, cultural designer. Lots of stuff goes way past just industrial design

03 Jul 14:45

Brian Hermelijn

--

Yeah I see concept artists as a industrial designer.

03 Jul 14:42

Amit Dutta

--

not talking about you guys..lol, just in general. :)

03 Jul 14:40

Amit Dutta

--

I wish they didn't even use the word artist when talking about concepting. It's more design really.

03 Jul 14:40

Mechanizoid

--

Oh, yeah, and habit forming, it is hard at the start!

03 Jul 14:39

Mechanizoid

--

We really have to study the same sort of stuff. :-)

03 Jul 14:38

Mechanizoid

--

Of course, it is important to be able to make a good looking picture as a concept artist as well, so those skill sets really overlap for both jobs.

03 Jul 14:38

Mechanizoid

--

Yes, composition is a very important fundamental for illustration.

03 Jul 14:25

Brian Hermelijn

--

The other areas like (value, perspective, form, shapes) I have a general understanding of them, just need to continue applying.

03 Jul 14:24

Brian Hermelijn

--

Well you could say for illustration, some areas I still need to delve into (the theory part) is composition and story telling.