22 Jun 03:36
--I think I degraded you into an object
Shout Box archive
22 Jun 03:35
--If you didn't catch the question the first time. What is 'good', subjectively, to this person, which is you, named Amit?
22 Jun 03:34
--Hitler did what was good for him. If he thought he it was a bad idea, he wouldn't do it. I didn't say he was morally correct. It's just that it was subjectively good for him.
22 Jun 03:34
--Honestly, John. I don't have a fundamental definition of good that will work for everyone. I have one that might work for me, but that's all it applies to in any practical sense
22 Jun 03:32
--Of course I do. That's why I'm asking you what was your definition of "good". If I needed the defacto meaning, I'd ask a dictionary
22 Jun 03:32
--You really think for example Hitler or Gengis thought they were evil bad people. Bet you they didn't
22 Jun 03:31
--Is everything I do considered good? I'd say yes. Like everyone else. If it's a bad thing, why would anyone do it?
22 Jun 03:31
--Yeah sure. trusting my gut doesn't mean I become a being solely operating on uncontrollable bodily impulse...but it does mean I discount a lot of the mental/emotiional bullshit that our minds make up just to fuck with us
22 Jun 03:30
--I mean, you can't be simply running everything though gut. What if your gut tells you to shit on the streets because you really need to defecate? Haha!
22 Jun 03:28
--Yeah and I'm posing a question back to get you to think about your question :)