06-29-2015, 08:59 PM
Does everyone believe that crits have purely a positive value? or can crits actually have a negative effect on a person?
How can you evaluate the value of a crit given your current skill level?
How can the person giving a crit evaluate how much they understood of the crit?
I was wondering about these things, Perhaps focusing on crits based on reciprocatory (no idea how to spell this) values is good in theory but in practice, is it a plus positive factor in your progress or a crutch to fall back on?
I think i really like this idea of helping someone else as well because it again creates a community cohesiveness.
Dennis: I think perhaps this is a point, if a forum is a place for deeper critical thought, maybe sketchbooks are not necessary for this. Because a forum is a meetingplace of ideas ever since the classical era. By Atomizing the meetingspace you are essentially diluting its power. However i think places like facebook and artstation have a great platform for promoting art i just dont see them as good places to get feedback.
How can you evaluate the value of a crit given your current skill level?
How can the person giving a crit evaluate how much they understood of the crit?
I was wondering about these things, Perhaps focusing on crits based on reciprocatory (no idea how to spell this) values is good in theory but in practice, is it a plus positive factor in your progress or a crutch to fall back on?
I think i really like this idea of helping someone else as well because it again creates a community cohesiveness.
Dennis: I think perhaps this is a point, if a forum is a place for deeper critical thought, maybe sketchbooks are not necessary for this. Because a forum is a meetingplace of ideas ever since the classical era. By Atomizing the meetingspace you are essentially diluting its power. However i think places like facebook and artstation have a great platform for promoting art i just dont see them as good places to get feedback.