06-29-2015, 11:44 PM
@Zearthus, great job! Keep that up. :) To be honest I was never one to crit on a lot of people's sketchbooks because I found it overwhelming to follow so many. I did end up following a few here and there of course and not often the most popular ones, but for the most part I would crit in the (funnily enough) crit threads and the abandoned hideout and of course outside of CD.
@Appleseed, from what I have seen, for the overwhelming majority crits are considered and taken to be good. I have seen a few horror crits which were just attacks and non-constructive, but for the most part I would say this isn't the case. In terms of judging value well....that is for the receiver to say alone. Most of the time people will say whether they found a crit useful or not.
and Dang you gave me an idea...we need an art wall where all uploaded images get posted to it automatically...so we can have a visual library of what is going down in all the sketchbooks. Like a shoutbox but for the image uploads
:P Don't worry Dennis I know that is a lot of work, and maybe impossible for a forum cms. Nice idea though.
@Appleseed, from what I have seen, for the overwhelming majority crits are considered and taken to be good. I have seen a few horror crits which were just attacks and non-constructive, but for the most part I would say this isn't the case. In terms of judging value well....that is for the receiver to say alone. Most of the time people will say whether they found a crit useful or not.
and Dang you gave me an idea...we need an art wall where all uploaded images get posted to it automatically...so we can have a visual library of what is going down in all the sketchbooks. Like a shoutbox but for the image uploads
:P Don't worry Dennis I know that is a lot of work, and maybe impossible for a forum cms. Nice idea though.