Crimson CHOW #46 - FANTASTICAL DESERT LANDS - FINALS

[darktiste]

If you want those challenge to become more umbrella it gonna be a little bit more complex to judge because now you compare sometime that more inanimate vs something that as composition and alot more fundamental.

Would you be more inclined to participate if it were a prop or weapon design challenge? There might be other people that would also go for that.

I really like Lege's idea of an umbrella topic, but you make a really good point that you can't really compare different types of art so it would be a fun prompt but there wouldn't be much competition involved if we did that. 

@CBinns Thanks! :) I've been debating working on it more to make it more polished because there was more I wanted to do but it keeps seeming like a lot of work lol. Also yeah I think it would be a good challenge. Maybe I'll make a post at some point and see what happens lol.

I don't think that there is no competitive aspect to concepting but the rule should probably not be the same as far as getting feedback from other. It should be about exploring and perfection decision making and good artistic taste and presentation under a deadline.

The problem with coming up with a design challenge is deciding how far it should go.Like how many iteration minimum what level of render and level of presentation.By iteration it refer to the number of preparatory different design we expect at minimum before a final design is choose.(Also should they be just simply scribble or silhouette or if we allow photo bashing preparatory iteration. For level of render do we expect a presentation in the style of a concept sheet with a turn around of the props and maybe some functional extra sketch that explain some aspect of the design in a similar fashion as an industrial design or are we presenting the final as a illustrative work.

Also how do we define turn around can varies some just do front and back some do front side and back some do front 3/4 back

Those are just the thought i would think about if i was those who had to come up with the requirement and limitation.

But i think what make sense is to look at successful art challenge outside and try to replicate it but to adapt it to what make sense over here.